Motor starter problem


I guess I need to replace this motor starter?  The last time it happened was five to six weeks ago.


Also, my question for today is:  Why does everyone always claim to loose $5.00 when something it broken?  It sure looked like $1.50 but that is just me.  Also, at Hueytown were it is $4.00 for 20 minutes, they still claim they put in $5.00.