I tested out all my 3 phase legs today. The 3 pictures show all the 3 voltages for all 3 legs.
The 41.9 Volts was obviously the problem so I traced the wire to the box and the wire fell out of the wire nut. Mep1 and Greg were correct with my problem with the motor starter: it was a wiring problem. What was weird was the motor starter was working fine then quit working. Problem solved. Thanks Mep1 and Greg.