The coin acceptor was just spitting out coins and did not hold them. Anyone who knows anything knows that this means the screw to determine the price has worked itself out.
I actually was able to screw the screw back in without removing the coin acceptor. The second picture shows why the coins get rejected. The last picture shows how it should be setup. I actually had no idea how to fix this. I had a spare and was going to throw the other away. I tested the new coin acceptor and then noticed the problem.